Rated 2.2 out of 5 by 18
Rated 1 out of 5 Ran out too quickly!
The brush on this pen was fantastic! I was really happy with it for the first few days after buying it, I even told all my friends that it was the best liquid eye liner u have ever used (and I've tried hundreds!). However after the 3rd/4th day it was starting to run out? Now a week later it is completely dried up which I am not very happy about! Considering its not exactly cheap I was very disappointed and would not buy again unless the product was developed to have a button like a concealer pen which kind of pumps out more liner? (Hard to describe). Other than that I was happy with the liner, it's very precise. However it just doesn't last long enough to be a regular buy.
23 August 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by Evie34 Really disappointed
I saw advertising for this product and thought it looked really good and that seeing as i had just run out of my last eyeliner that I would buy it. First of all you need to apply to about 5 times to actually get a black line... Secondly I had had it on for about an hour and when I looked in a mirror it had smudged everywhere, I hadn't been in the rain or doing anything apart from sitting down talking, no way is this eyeliner waterproof like it advertises! This eyeliner is a complete waste of money and I don't recommend it to anyone.
05 June 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by laurenrk Not too bad
I had the same problem as most people when using this for the first time and for a while after. On your bare eye alone, it hardly does anything. I actually stopped using it for a while after just a few times trying to use it because I thought it dried up but, after playing around with it for a while I started getting pretty decent color from it. My tip is to apply it on top of eyeshadow. I use eyeshadow primer, eyeshadow and then this. I get a solid black and only have to go over it once more for just a touch up.
03 July 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by jnell92 liquid liner
This liquid eyeliner is horrible. Like everyone else said, you literally have to go over it 5 times in order for it to even show up. The tip is so hard it feels like you are using a marker on your lid. I got this eyeliner because I ran out of my Smashbox felt tip liquid eyeliner (which is amazing) I thought this eyeliner would be perfect for a cat eye because of the shape of it, but because of it not showing up, it didn't work for that at all. I went to the store the next day and bought a smashbox eyeliner.
18 June 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by Anna32 I wanted to like this so bad!
So I love eyeliner pens and I had recently tried your mascara brand so thought I'd give this a go. I was really disappointed it went on ok I guess but the tip was so hard that it didn't go on smooth at all. It skipped a lot when you drew the line and made a cat eye very hard to accomplish. I also felt the pen dried out super quickly. I didn't get a very long life with it. I won't repurchase sadly. The formula seemed good the packaging just was a miss.
25 September 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by KirstenD Mediocre Lines
I'm a devout Rimmel London user but this is the first, and I think, the only Rimmel product that I was disappointed with. The lines are dull which means you have to go over them about four or five times before you get an actual black line on your lid. I usually use it to fill in or trace over my gel liner once it's dried. I recommend doing that because it actually makes the gel liner appear darker than it actually is.
23 May 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by momo27 rubbish
Been using collection 2000 liquid eyeliner and have been very happy with it as it's waterproof and wanted to try something different. So thought I'd try this pen.
Its very easy to put on but it is stated that it is waterproof when it's not it rubs off very easily. And would have to freshen it up lay on in the day.
It's not value for money. I'll be going back to my old one.
25 August 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Niceeyes Does NoT smudge at all
This product has the least amount of chemical ingredients (and no parabens) than any other liquid/pen eyeliner at the drugstores. It is perfect for criers and people who use eye drops because the eyeliner does not smudge! It does not lighten either; it stays intact perfectly. It doesn't clump like other eyeliners, and it doesn't get on your eyelashes. I love it! Thank you
31 July 2014