Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 138
Rated 1 out of 5 by BgBunny USED THIS A LONG TIME, DONT LIKE CHANGES
I love the product but plan on looking for something else. I have used this product a long time. When I first started using it they did sell a gloss separately and even one that was in a gold tube and had some shimmer for that was nice for going out rather than just for work. Also I did not have trouble with the gloss falling off the tube like I do now. I hate it when companies have something good and then change it for the worse. I plan on contacting Maybelline about this. I understand that they might make more money by not selling the gloss separately forcing you to buy a whole new tube but they could set the pricing on the glosses to make up for it. Disappointed!
10 November 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 ABSOLUTE FAVORITE.
I purchased this lip stain in Reliable Raspberry, and it is my absolute favorite lip color that I own! Being a student, I don't like to be constantly leaving class to reapply. This lipstick lasts me all day, and it only comes off during my music class, when I play an instrument. Even then, not so much. I don't find it anymore difficult to take off than my other makeup, and I've received many compliments on it! It isn't drying at all, but make sure you use the balm it comes with to moisturize... any other balm will make the stain come off more quickly. Overall, this lip stain is so so amazing. I love it.
08 April 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by RobertaJ Could be better
I really like this product but the lipstick way out lasts the lip balm so I end up with alot of lipstick that I can not use and this is a huge waste of money. Also the balm end of the tube never stays on. It just doesn't clasp on tight enough to hold. I never had this problem until they changed from the old style. This is enough for me to look at a different mfg to buy my lipstick from. what would be really nice is if you could sell the lip balm sepeately in addition to the one that comes with the lipstick. I also see in the reviews that I have read every one is saying the same thing. Please fix this and make your customers happy. Please give me a reason to continue buying Maybelline Products
25 August 2012
Rated 4 out of 5 by LisaEC70 Awesome Product! Would get a 5 if packaged better!
I love these products! I apply the color it in the morning and then other than refreshing the top coat whenever you are feeling the need, you are good to go for the day! You get a ton of applications out of it so you aren't replacing every month or so like I did with traditional lipsticks. My only criticism is not of the product but of the way they made the gloss end. It does not stay in. They are always floating around in my purse because they come undone from the main tube. If they could create a tighter fit, or a way to lock it into place then I would give a 5 star rating all the way!!
18 August 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by MaryChica does not stay on
this does not stay on for me at all, I put it on right before I walk in my office and with in the half hour it is off. I drink coffee but no eating. I have noticed that at the end of the use of the tube my lips are entirely chapped. So I spend the next week applying any form of lip repair balm. Which I hate being without color on my lips but it has happened over and over. I think this is thelast time I use this. I need to find a new one As much as I love the products that do not have you reapplying this one is not working and why am I getting the chapped lips at the end of usage
16 October 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 Not so hot
I bought this in hopes of getting a long-wearing lipcolor that had a lot of shine (with the added balm, of course). What I got was flaky, drying, and uneven. I followed the instructions, applying a thin layer to clean, dry lips. I've been using the balm repeatedly throughout the day, too. Right after I apply the balm, it looks nice, but after just a little while of wear, it goes back to drying out and flaking. I've even got little bits of the flaking all over the balm. It's too bad I didn't buy this at a CVS or somewhere I could return this and get my money back!
14 January 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by Linds22 HATE IT!!
I'm tired of "long-lasting" lipcolors making my lips feel as if they will crumble to the touch because of how hard these lipsticks make them. This lipstick (step 1) cracked my lips instantly, and stained it weird. Sure, step 2 made them feel a little better, but it dries out eventually as well. I had to go into the bathroom to wash it off my face, because it wasn't as easy as wiping off with a kleenex. I bought 2 of them. The one I used, this one time, went right into the garbage can. I guess I have to return the other one tonight. Very disappointed.
12 December 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by Kaz26 Disappointed
I used the old superstay for several years and loved it. The new range of colours is disappointing. I find them mostly too dark and only one of the lighter shades suits my colouring. This product is not cost effective. the top coat doesn't last long enough and cannot be purchased separately as in the old product. It is frustrating to have to repurchase the whole product just because the top coat runs out long before the colour coat. On a positive note, it does live up to it's claim of longwear and not transferring which is essential for me.
10 May 2013